Does it matter if you have enough, if you don’t feel like you do?
I find this a complicated question to answer.
I’ll give you the background first…
The other day I was sitting outside at my parents’ house, enjoying a relaxing Sunday afternoon by the pool (social distancing of course) and the question of class came up. Yes, it was a political conversation (my mom loves to talk politics), but I’m really not that into it. However, I do like to throw her a bone here and there and get her riled up, what good son wouldn’t do that to his mother? Hahaha.
And the topic that seems to always come up in our conversations over the years is the middle class. What is this middle class? Because it seems like whoever you talk to, has a different opinion.
But in this article, I have no intention of getting into the debate of how to define it. I’ll be straightforward, I don’t really care, split the hairs how you want to, that’s up to you.
However, the more interesting part to me, is what part of the middle class a person FEELS that they are a part of.
Are you lower, middle or upper? How great are your struggles? Or are what you consider struggles, not even struggles to a normal person at all?
Because as we progressed further into the conversation, I asked my Mom did she feel like she had enough money throughout her life? Did she feel like she provided enough for our family? And her answer to me was an emphatic: NO – both my parents always felt as if they were scraping to get by.
And I’ll be honest, that surprised me.
Because when I look at them on the outside, they look like the perfect example of the quintessential middle class American family – seeming to have had more than enough throughout their lives, due to hard work, dedication and sacrifice. And from a son’s perspective, I’ve always felt that they provided for our family just fine. They live in a modest home in a wealthy area now and they each retired at 67 and should easily be taken care of for the rest of their lives based on the assets they have accumulated. They never really planned their retirement out, yet it all just kind of worked out that way. They were definitely lucky they did the right things, which unfortunately isn’t the case for most.
But it is clear, based on the numbers, my parents have enough (catastrophic long-term care aside). Yet when I ask them how they feel, it is just as clear that they obviously don’t feel that they do have enough.
I find this fascinating, and it made me think deeply about the following question: Does it really matter if you have enough, if you don’t FEEL like you have enough?
Probably not. But is this simply dependent on the person? I don’t know.
Or is this more of a marketing gimmick? You see so much advertising on TV, your smart phone, or being caught up in the public opinion of what you need to have… should have by a certain age, that it’s impossible to ignore all the desires surrounding us.
Because whether we try to tune out the noise or not, the truth is that we are continuously and subconsciously being fed what success is supposed to look like in a capitalistic society like America.
And if you think the FIRE community is an exception to this, you need to set down that cup of cool aid and dig a little deeper my friend.
Because let’s be honest, there’s a lot of false pride among the FIRE community, as well as pressure to look a certain way, talk a certain way, live a certain way. Conformity is embraced and challenging sacred beliefs is shunned. And if you’re lucky enough to be a novice in this arena, your head is probably on a swivel from all the smoke and mirrors – the do-or-die budgeters, frugal obsessives, homestead environmentalists, wanna-be life-style design gurus, side hustle hystericals, shameless bloggers (of course myself included!), ESG investors that will save the world, book-deal egoists and podcaster irrelevants. There is a whole lot of bullshit you gotta wade through before you get to the simple principles that can really change your life.
Unfortunately, polarizing extremes have become the standard and are shoved down your throat rather than promoting small incremental changes to slowly and thoughtfully apply to your life.
And I understand that. Look, there’s images to uphold, egos to massage and most importantly, money to be made! I get that. The simple advice doesn’t get people to click on affiliate links. It’s fine. I understand brands and personas are based on being anti-mainstream and the thumbing your nose at the status quo. You gotta make your dollar just like everyone else and promote the lifestyle, or else how else are you going to retire early or maintain that passive cashflow? Hahaha… it’s hard to tell if I’m being a dick or really give a shit about this, right? Because the point is it doesn’t matter one bit.
The point is, when people take the time to finally calm down, and look themselves in the mirror, put aside the self-righteousness in the game of masks and independent rhetoric. I think we’ll find a weight that we all can relate to pressing down on us. The weight of sometimes I don’t feel like I have enough, even when I’m surrounded by so much.
No one is immune to this.
And there’s nothing wrong with that. I think this is as natural as the blink of the eye or goosebumps on flesh. Yet, we fight it, because we see it as weakness. We feel it as guilt. And sometimes it manifests as shame.
But when we strip away the layers guarding our most inner thoughts, we find a brittle honesty more delicate and frailer than we would like to admit. Some bury and hide it better than others under dominant personality traits, but there’s still nonetheless, a subtle current flowing under the surface that never stops, lapping swells of anxiety and unease merging as one.
Because the numbers might tell one story, but it’s our guarded emotions that determine who we are and what we truly think. And human nature doesn’t like fear. We like to play pretend that uncertainty isn’t real, that we can predict the future like the gods of time we wish we were.
But we can’t. No matter how many times we smash the mirror-mirror-on-the-wall, we still don’t know what mortality has in store for us… and never will.
So that brings us back to the most important question at the crux of our problem with ourselves:
How much is enough?
Why do so many financially independent people still make money? Is it because they’re worried they might not have enough? Or is it more that they don’t have any other way to value their time. They’re still stuck in the same old game of capitalism.
And I don’t have an answer to this. I just find it interesting once again – why do people do what they do? Not what they say why they’re doing it, but by looking at their actions only. Because I’ve found you learn the most about people by watching what they do, not by listening to what they say. That old cliché – actions speak louder than words, has never rung so true.
Because what we have, versus what we feel we have, are two entirely separate things.
Anyway, wow, what a fucking sideways mind fuck I just wandered down.
I gotta wrap this up, so getting back on track, my main point is that I think I will always struggle with battling the psychology of feeling like I don’t have enough versus knowing that I have enough. This will never go away, just as a doom’s day scenario will always be possible, no matter how small the odds.
Is it a terrible problem to have? No. Not really.
But it’s something that affects my mindset… probably, from time to time.
And where do I fit in with the middle class? I stopped caring about that a long time ago. The definition lies in the eyes of the beholder, and last time I checked, there’s way too many chefs in the kitchen to allow that precious sand in the hourglass to slip through my grasp.
-Q-FI
—
P.S. Yep, you know what question is coming. Have you ever struggled with feeling like you have enough?
Mr. Fate says
Great article Q-FI and always a great question for folks to ponder. I suspect everyone individual’s answer will be somewhat different. I’ve been having a lot of personal reflection on my own “enough” recently. However, it’s been focused on that finite, ever depreciating currency known as Time.
While I’m extremely grateful for the time I’ve had (and hopefully will have), I do not feel that there’s “enough” left (even with a good run) to do/see/experience before the account is depleted But, that’s good since it informs the decisions I make today.
Back to your real question – I’ve been lucky in that I’ve always had a semblance of health, love, friendship, food in my belly and a roof over my head. So while the amount/quality may have varied slightly over time, I’ve always felt as if I had “enough.”
Q-FI says
You’re asking the right question thinking about time. I’m actually working on another post right now that addresses this very question. I think the older we get, the more attuned to it we become, which is natural and relatively straightforward. But we live in a society that likes to slip mortality under the rug and never address the tough topics head on. The only guarantee in life is that we each have an end date, yet very few people can live a life in tune with this understanding.
I’m glad your financial independence is bringing to light what really matters.
Steveark says
I’ve always had much more money than I needed. And now I have much more than I will ever spend. I don’t understand how you could know you have plenty and still feel like you don’t have enough. Maybe it’s the engineer in me but I believe in math.
Q-FI says
Thanks for chiming in Steveark and I find your comments very interesting.
I think your first sentence, “I’ve always had much more money than I needed.” Answers your third sentence, “I don’t understand how you could know you have plenty and still feel like you don’t have enough.”
I’ll be fostering soon and if you are a child that has grown up in poverty or had to wonder where your next meal might come from, this leaves deep emotional and psychological scars. It’s amazing how much damage can be done and quickly to a developing mind – and these scars do not leave you. So for someone who comes from a background of never having enough money, feeling like they have enough even if they have accumulated wealth, has nothing to do with math. It’s a psychological problem.
I’ll also say that math is only as good as the inputs. If you don’t know the future, which no one does, people still might not feel like they have enough when facing uncertainty. Sure if you have millions, the odds of you running out of money are low. But most people are not in that situation.
steveark says
Thank you for such a thoughtful answer. When I wrote that comment I was way into left brain world. I am an engineer and I do try to force math over feelings, a lot. But I also come from a place of great undeserved privilege and lack of want that gives me a world view through rose colored glasses. I’m so impressed with fostering, of course you would do that. Your point on math is valid. Sure I have a super low withdrawal rate. But does a pandemic, or a nuclear strike or an asteroid really care how low my safe withdrawal rate is? Or even a drunk driver or a blood clot? Math fails when we don’t have the necessary inputs to solve an algorithm. And none of us do. Again, thanks for what you do and the thoughtful and humane way you do it.
Q-FI says
No worries at all Steveark – I assumed you were taking the question literal but just expanded on it a little bit. From your past comments you’ve shown a remarkable ability to use logic over emotion which is a trait I’ve always envied you for. I think that skill probably served you very well in how high you climbed the corporate ladder.
I always enjoy reading your comments bud and hearing your perspective.
Katie Camel says
Great post! I have similar thoughts all the time, and fear of not having enough continually drives me to want to work past my FI date. I recognize that my needs and wants will change over time and the cost of long term care insurance and health care scare me. I don’t want to give up working too early only to have everything I’ve accumulated not be enough. That said, I feel that I have more than enough on my middle class salary, though I wish I had much more time.
Q-FI says
What’s up Katie? Healthcare also makes me nervous. If I could have figured out healthcare by now, or if there was an easy solution, I think I might have already have left my job. I also think the natural fear of having enough plays into the one more year syndrome. It’s tough to finally cut ties with that 9 to 5 and put everything on the line. Sure the numbers, can say you’re okay, but that’s only based off of models. You get one of your assumptions wrong and there’s always risk.
Ahhhhh time… yep. I think we’ll always be wishing for more.
freddy smidlap says
i think i’ve always felt that i have had enough even when i had very little on paper. the complicating factor is feeling a sense of responsibility to not screw up mrs. smidlap’s future. i’ll happily work longer to make sure she is fine. i could go back to eating gravel and road kill if need be.
i really enjoyed your rant on putting on the big show and especially the irrelevant podcasters. that had me cracking up. also, i won’t lie when i say i really like some of the extras in life. if you handed me a million bucks i would have no trouble spending it.
Q-FI says
Hahaha… thanks Freddy. I’m glad you enjoyed the rant – I don’t know, sometimes I just go down these sideways mind rabbles. But I also enjoy some of the extras in life. No shame nor problem with that!
Like you, if the family needs it, I’d keep working forever. Gotta take care of your loved ones first.